Skip to Main Content
Carsonie's - Upper Arlington logo topCarsonie's - Upper Arlington logo scroll
  • (614)-481-5555
  • carsonies1@gmail.com
  • 1725 West Lane Avenue , Columbus
  • ONLINE ORDER
    ORDER - UPPER ARLINGTON ORDER - WESTERVILLE
  • UPPER ARLINGTON MENU
  • WESTERVILLE MENU
  • CATERING
    CATERING - UPPER ARLINGTON CATERING - WESTERVILLE
  • EVENTS
  • PARTIES
    PARTIES - UPPER ARLINGTON PARTIES - WESTERVILLE
  • GIFT CARDS
    GIFT CARDS - UPPER ARLINGTON GIFT CARDS - WESTERVILLE
  • CARSONIE'S APPAREL
  • JOBS
    JOBS - UPPER ARLINGTON JOBS - WESTERVILLE
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Carsonie's - Upper Arlington logo topCarsonie's - Upper Arlington logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • ONLINE ORDER
  • UPPER ARLINGTON MENU
  • WESTERVILLE MENU
  • CATERING
  • EVENTS
  • PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • CARSONIE'S APPAREL
  • JOBS
  • CATERING - UPPER ARLINGTON
  • CATERING - WESTERVILLE
  • PARTIES - UPPER ARLINGTON
  • PARTIES - WESTERVILLE
  • JOBS - UPPER ARLINGTON
  • JOBS - WESTERVILLE
  • ORDER - UPPER ARLINGTON
  • ORDER - WESTERVILLE
  • GIFT CARDS - UPPER ARLINGTON
  • GIFT CARDS - WESTERVILLE

our menu
Westerville

MenuCatering

Soup and Salad

Traditional Wedding Soup

$5.00
$6.00
House-made salad dressings: Italian, balsamic, raspberry vinaigrette, ranch, bleu cheese, and Caesar Honey mustard, French, and fat-free Italian oil/vinegar available!
House Salad photo

House Salad

$6.00
$10.00
Mixed greens, pickled cucumbers, tomatoes, carrots, and cheese with your choice of dressing on the side

Caesar Salad

$6.00
$10.00
Romaine, freshly shaved parmesan, and garlic croutons tossed in our house-made creamy Caesar dressing | *Add grilled chicken for $2.99 | **Entrée Salads are all served with a homemade roll.

Carsonie's Chopped Salad

$13.00
Mixed greens, Roma tomatoes, pickled cucumbers, red onions, and roasted red peppers tossed in our balsamic dressing and topped with EITHER salami, Capicola ham OR gilled chicken and shredded parmesan cheese

Cobb Salad

$13.00
Mixed greens topped with grilled chicken, Roma tomatoes, bacon, black olives, bleu cheese crumbles, and hardboiled egg served with your choice of dressing on the side

BBQ Chicken Salad

$13.00
Mixed greens topped with Roma tomatoes, black beans, corn, grilled BBQ chicken, chopped cilantro, and crispy tortilla strips with house-made ranch on the side
Cranberry Walnut Grilled Chicken Salad photo

Cranberry Walnut Grilled Chicken Salad

$13.00
Mixed greens, baby spinach, and grilled chicken tossed in our house-made Italian and topped with house-made candied walnuts, dried cranberries, and bleu cheese crumbles

Greek Salad

$7.00
$10.00
Fresh lettuce, topped with Kalamata olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, banana peppers, feta cheese with our delicious homemade Greek Balsamic dressing

Caprese Salad

$13.00
Fresh Tomatoes, Mozzarella Cheese, Basil drizzled with Balsamic and Olive Oil

Appetizers

Italian Fries photo

Italian Fries

$8.00
Strips of our house-made dough lightly fried and tossed in parmesan and served with marinara for dipping

Carsonie's Ultimate Loaded Fries

$11.00
Our famous parmesan French fries topped with melted cheese, bacon, and pepperoni and served with house-made ranch

Frankie's Fried Pickle Spears -NEW!

$10.00
Breaded Dill Pickle spears served w/ homemade spicy ranch

Calamari

$13.00
Crispy calamari rings fried with banana peppers and served with a side of marinara topped with feta cheese

Bavarian Pretzels

$10.00
Served with homemade honey mustard sauce
Meatball Sliders photo

Meatball Sliders

$11.00
Four mini-meatball sandwiches topped with melted cheese and banana peppers and served with our parmesan French fries
Award-Winning Chicken Wings photo

Award-Winning Chicken Wings

$14.00
One pound of our bone-in wings (8-9)tossed in your choice of house-made sauces. Served with celery and your choice of bleu cheese or ranch | *Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ and Sweet Heat are available

Boneless Chicken Wings

$12.00
A pound of our boneless wings tossed in your choice of house-made sauces. Served with celery and your choice of bleu cheese or ranch | *Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ , Garlic Parmesan or Sweet Heat are available

Mozzarella Sticks

$10.00
Chunks of fresh mozzarella coated in our house-made Italian bread crumbs, lightly fried and served with marinara

Buffalo Cauliflower Bites- NEW!

$12.00
Fresh Cauliflower, breaded and tossed in our homemade Buffalo sauce

Garlic Cheese Bread

$8.00
House-made bread toasted with olive oil, garlic, and melted cheese and served with marinara

Sandwiches

All sandwiches are served hot and with your choice of parmesan French fries or wedding soup or house salad for $12

Sausage and Peppers

$12.00
Slow-cooked Italian sausage topped with sautéed roasted red peppers, green peppers, and onions

The Italian Stallion

$12.00
Savory ham, salami, and Capicola ham topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onion, banana peppers, provolone cheese, and balsamic dressing

Millie's Meatball Hoagie

$12.00
House-made meatballs topped with melted provolone, banana peppers, and marinara

The Godfather

$12.00
A prime steak hoagie with sautéed roasted red peppers, green pepper, mushrooms, and onion topped with melted provolone, lettuce, and tomatoes and served with creamy horseradish sauce

The Godmother

$12.00
Lightly fried chicken breast topped with marinara, melted provolone, lettuce, and tomatoes

Columbus' Best Fish Sandwich

$12.00
Beer-battered cod topped with lettuce and tomatoes and served with a side of tartar sauce

Veggie Hoagie

$12.00
Fresh mushrooms, roasted red peppers, spinach, tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella with a light basil pesto spread

Buffalo Chicken Philly

$12.00
Grilled chicken strips, green peppers, and red onions sautéed in our spicy buffalo sauce and topped with melted provolone, lettuce, and tomatoes

Half-Pound Angus Burger

$12.00
Cooked to order and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and onion | *Add provolone, American, or bleu cheese for an additional charge

Stromboli

Small (serves 1-2) | Large (serves 2-4) ~ Add Additional Toppings to Your Stromboli: SM - 1.00 LG - 2.25 *All strombolis are made-to-order and customizable

Original photo

Original

$14.00/Small
$24.00/Large
Stuffed with pepperoni, sausage, mozzarella, and provolone cheese and served with a side of marinara

Chicken

$14.00/Small
$24.00/Large
Stuffed with grilled chicken, tomatoes, diced banana peppers, mozzarella, and provolone cheese and served with a side of marinara

Veggie

$14.00/Small
$24.00/Large
Stuffed full of red onions, artichokes, tomatoes, black olives, mozzarella, and provolone cheese and served with a side of marinara

Pesto Veggie

$14.00/Small
$24.00/Large
Housemade pesto, red peppers, tomatoes, spinach, mozzarella, and provolone cheese and served with a side of marinara

Buffalo Chicken

$14.00/Small
$24.00/Large
Buffalo sauce, chicken, red onions, tomatoes, mozzarella, and provolone cheese and served with a side of marinara

Toppings:

Pepperoni | Sausage | Meatball | Salami | Ham | Chicken | Bacon | Anchovies | Green Peppers | Banana Peppers | Red Onion | Black Olives | Green Olives | Tomatoes | Pineapple | Artichokes | Mushrooms | Roasted Red Peppers | Spinach | Jalapeños | Fresh Mozzarella | Whipped Ricotta | Feta Cheese | Extra Cheese

Breakfast Stromboli

$14.00
$24.00
Our homemade dough, stuffed with Bacon, Sausage, Scrambled eggs and mozzarella cheese, served with a side of Maple Syrup or Cajun Alfredo

Entrées

All entrées are served with a house-made roll. Add a house or Caesar salad for $4.50

Spaghetti and Meatballs

$14.00
Two house-made Italian meatballs tossed in marinara and served on a bed of spaghetti

Eggplant Parmesan

$14.00
Fresh eggplant breaded and baked topped with marinara and melted provolone and served on a bed of spaghetti

Baked Ziti

$15.00
Chunks of meatball, Italian sausage, and pepperoni tossed in our house-made marinara and topped with melted provolone cheese

Pesto Chicken Pasta

$15.00
Grilled chicken sautéed in olive oil, basil pesto, tomatoes, spinach, and spaghetti

Chicken Carsonie

$15.00
Lightly breaded chicken breast topped with marinara and melted provolone and served on a bed of spaghetti Alfredo

Lasagna

$14.00
Layers of fresh pasta, Italian sausage, ground beef, ricotta, house-made marinara, mozzarella, and provolone cheeses baked to perfection

Ravioli

$13.00
Six cheese ravioli tossed in our tomato cream sauce and topped with melted provolone
Pasta Rosa photo

Pasta Rosa

$15.00
Penne, grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, spinach, and mushrooms all tossed in our creamy red pepper sauce

Mediterranean Pasta

$15.00
Penne pasta with your choice of chicken or shrimp sautéed with olive oil, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, and feta cheese ...

From the Oven

From the Oven

Since our stromboli and pizza start from scratch, please allow up to 30-45 minutes for these dishes

Calzone

Calzone

$14.00
A personal-sized, oven-baked turnover that’s stuffed with our house-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, and provolone cheese and your choice of two additional toppings.

Pizza

Build your own pizza starting with our freshly made dough. Choose between our traditional house-made red sauce or our white pizza lightly brushed with garlic and olive oil. Add your choice of fresh toppings and our mozzarella and provolone cheese blend. Pizzas are served with our traditional thick crust with thin available upon request.

Cheese

$10.00/8"
$14.00/12"
$15.00/14"

Veggie Pizza

$12.00/8"
$16.00/12"
$20.00/14"
Green peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, black olives
Deluxe Pizza photo

Deluxe Pizza

$13.00/8"
$17.00/12"
$21.00/14"
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions

Meats Pizza

$14.00/8"
$18.00/12"
$22.00/14"
Our mozzarella and provolone blend topped with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, and salami

The Falcon

$13.00/8"
$18.00/12"
$22.00/14"
Shawn Haines' legendary creation of Sweet Heat Base, Fresh Jalapenos, Chicken, Bacon, Feta cheese, Mozzarella cheese & Ranch drizzle

Frank’s Favorite Pizza

$13.00/8"
$17.00/12"
$19.00/14"
Our white pizza topped with tomatoes, spinach, mozzarella, provolone, and feta cheese

Extra Topping $1 | $1.75 | $2.25

Pepperoni | Sausage | Meatball | Salami | Ham | Chicken | Bacon | Anchovies | Green Peppers | Banana Peppers | Red Onion | Black Olives | Green Olives | Tomatoes | Pineapple | Artichokes | Mushrooms | Roasted Red Peppers | Spinach | Jalapeños | Fresh Mozzarella | Whipped Ricotta | Feta Cheese | Extra Cheese

Chicken $2 | $3 | $4

Cauliflower Thin Crust Pizza

$12.00
Thin, Crispy, Healthy, 11" Pizza with your choice of toppings

Flatbreads

Buffalo Chicken

$15.00
Light cheese, grilled chicken tossed in our homemade wing sauce, tomatoes, light onions and finished with a ranch drizzle​

Pesto Chicken

$15.00
Pesto base, light cheese, tomatoes, red peppers, chicken, and feta cheese

Sicilian

$15.00
Pizza sauce, light cheese, salami, Capicola, and banana peppers

Frank’s Special

$15.00
Oil and garlic base, light cheese, tomatoes, spinach, and feta cheese

Chicken Caesar

$15.00
Caesar dressing base, light cheese, chicken, tomatoes, and topped with romaine

BBQ Chicken

$15.00
Light cheese, BBQ chicken, jalapeños, onions, and finished with a ranch drizzle

Just for Kids

This is only for kids 10 and under. All Items include a beverage (no refills on juices or milk) and a gift from our treasure box for only $6

Spaghetti and Meatball

$6.00
Spaghetti served with our homemade marinara and meatball on the side with a homemade roll

Penne Noodles

$6.00
Tossed in butter and served with a side of marinara and a homemade roll

Pizza Mia

$6.00
French bread style pizza with your choice of cheese or pepperoni

Meatball Sliders

$6.00
Two meatball sandwiches served with a side of French fries or steamed broccoli

Breaded Chicken Bites

$6.00
Served with a side of French fries or steamed broccoli
Grilled Cheese photo

Grilled Cheese

$6.00
Served with a side of French fries or steamed broccoli

Dessert

Tiramisu

$6.00
Coffee liquor and Marsala soaked sponge cake layered with smooth mascarpone, drizzled with coffee syrup

Chocolate Cake

$6.00
Our five-layer moist chocolate cake with chocolate cream icing

Snickers' Pie

$5.00

Brownie Sundae

$7.00
Brownie bites topped with vanilla bean ice cream and covered in chocolate syrup with whipped cream and a cherry on top

Sticky Fingers

$6.00
Strips of our house-made dough sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar and drizzled with icing

Elephant Ear

$5.00
A large side of house-made dough deep-fried and sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar

Chocolate Chip Cannoli's

$6.00
Three mini cannoli shells filled with a sweet ricotta chocolate chip filling

Nutella Stromboli

$9.00
Nutella spread across our homemade dough, baked, sprinkled w/ powdered sugar and a scoop of Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

Half pans typically feed between 9-12 people and full pans between 15-25 people, depending on appetites.

Salads and Soup

Garden Salad

$43.00
$79.00
w/ Choice of Homemade Dressing

Caesar Salad

$43.00
$79.00
w/ Homemade Dressing, Croutons, Shaved Parmesan

Chopped Salad

$55.00
$99.00
w/ Fresh Italian Meats, Veggies, Mixed Greens, Balsamic

Candied Walnut Cranberry Grilled Chicken Salad

$55.00
$99.00
w/ Candied Walnuts, Cranberries, Spinach, Greens

Cobb Salad

$55.00
$99.00
w/ Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Eggs, Tomatoes, Olives, Bleu Cheese

BBQ Chicken Salad

$55.00
$99.00
w/ Tomatoes, Corn, Black Beans, Tortilla Strips, Greens

Homemade Italian Wedding Soup

$16.00/quart

Appetizers and Sides

Jumbo Chicken Wings

$59.00
$118.00
Mild, Medium, Hot, Sweet Heat, BBQ

Italian Fries

$15.00
$29.00

Tomato, Mozzarella, Basil Skewers

$3.00/each

Garlic Bread Baked

$23.00
$39.00
w/ Mozzarella, Provolone

Meatball Sliders

$2.50/each

1/2 Pan Calamari

$55.00

2 Ounce Meatball

$2.75/each

Antipasti

$4.00/per person
Assorted Italian Meats, Cheeses, Olives, Roasted Peppers

Marinara Sauce

$10.00/quart

Homemade Italian Dressing

$4.00/quart
$10.00/8oz

Homemade Alfredo Sauce

$11.00/quart

Cauliflower Crust Pizza (Gluten Free)

$13.00/11"

Sausage and Peppers

$49.00
$98.00

Veggie Tray

$45.00
$115.00
Seasonal Vegetables served on decorative trays w/ Homemade Ranch for Dipping

Italian Sausage, Peppers, Onions

$55.00
$110.00
Sauteed and perfect for a side item

Entrées

Chicken Carsonie

$55.00
$110.00
Breaded Chicken w/ Provolone, Marinara w/ Pasta Tossed in Alfredo

Chicken Parmesan

$55.00
$110.00
Breaded Chicken w/ Provolone, Marinara w/ Pasta Tossed in Marinara

Baked Ziti

$55.00
$105.00
w/ Italian Meats

Vegetable Baked Ziti

$44.00
$88.00
With Grilled Vegetables, Marinara

Pasta Rosa

$55.00
$110.00
w/ Grilled Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Mushrooms, Rosa Sauce

Spaghetti/Penne

$48.00
$96.00
w/ Meatballs

Pesto Chicken Pasta

$55.00
$110.00
w/ cherry tomatoes, spinach, parmesan

Lasagna

$48.00
$96.00
w/ Italian Sausage, Ground Beef, Ricotta

Mediterranean Pasta

$55.00
$110.00
Choice of Shrimp or Chicken, Feta, Spinach, Tomatoes, Olive Oil

Strombolis

Strombolis are our specialty, as well as the long-time favorite of our patrons because it can be tailored to your taste. One large stromboli typically has about 15 pieces and can feed between 2-5 people, depending on appetites. Our dough is made fresh daily and our most popular strombolis are:

"The Original"

$24.00
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mozzarella, provolone

"Chicken"

$24.00
Grilled chicken, Roma tomatoes, banana peppers, cheeses

"Veggie"

$24.00
Artichokes, tomatoes, black olives, onions

Buffalo Chicken

$24.00
Grilled chicken tossed in our homemade buffalo sauce, tomatoes, onions, cheese

Pesto Chicken

$24.00
Grilled Chicken, Red Peppers, Spinach, cheese and pesto (Can also be made without chicken )

Desserts

Tiramisu

$60.00/15 pieces

Chocolate Cake

$66.00/14 slices

Sticky Fingers

$22.00
$40.00
Strips of dough, fried, sprinkled w/ cinnamon, sugar, icing

Chocolate Chip Canoli

$2.50/each
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs