Menu for Carsonie's Westerville


Garlic Cheese Bread Toasted with olive oil, garlic and melted provolone & mozzarella cheese, served with homemade marinara sauce $4.99
Italian Fries Our house-made dough cut into strips and deep fried, lightly dusted with romano cheese, served with a side of marinara for dipping $6.49
Calamari Crispy calamari rings fried with banana peppers until crisp, sprinkled with red pepper flakes & parmesan cheese served with our house lemon aioli $8.99
Meatball Sliders Four small meatball sandwiches with provolone and mozzarella cheese, topped with banana peppers and served with parmesan fries. $7.99
Buffalo Chicken Wings Choose our award winning wings in bone-in or boneless, served with celery and your choice of bleu cheese or ranch dressing. Your choice of mild, medium, hot, BBQ or sweet heat 10 wings-$9.79
Mozzarella & Marinara Fresh chunks of mozzarella coated with Italian bread crumbs and pan fried, served with zesty marinara $6.99
Carsonie's Ultimate Loaded Fries Delicious french fries topped with melted provolone & mozzarella cheese , crispy bacon and pepperoni, served with a side of house-made ranch dressing for dipping $7.99
Homemade Flatbread Special House-made dough with the Chef's choice of fresh ingredients, changes daily $9.99


Dressings Include: Italian, Balsamic, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard, Caesar and Fat-Free Italian. Oil & Vinegar also available.

Wedding Soup with meatballs, carrots, chicken and pasta beads. try a cup or bowl $3.99

House Salad Iceberg & romaine lettuce, pickled cucumbers, tomatoes, olives, pizza cheese and your choice of dressing on the side $4.25 - add grilled chicken $3
Caesar Romaine, freshly shaved parmesan cheese, garlic croutons tossed in our creamy caesar dressing -add grilled chicken $3 $4.99, lg.$7.99
Carsonie's Chopped Salad House lettuce mix, roma tomatoes, pickled cucumbers, red onions and roasted red peppers topped with salami, capicola ham, provolone & mozzarella blend tossed in our balsamic vinaigrette $10.99
Tuscan Chicken Salad Grilled chicken, penne pasta, mixed greens, red onions, roma tomatoes, shaved parmesan and raspberry vinaigrette dressing $10.99
Candied Walnut and Cranberry Salad Grilled chicken, mixed greens, baby spinach, homemade candied walnuts, dried cranberries and bleu cheese crumbles tossed with our house-made Italian dressingg $10.99
BBQ Chicken Salad Mixed greens with grilled BBQ chicken topped with roma tomatoes, black beans, corn, crispy tortilla strips, chopped cilantro served with our homemade ranch dressing $10.99
Cobb Salad Grilled chicken on top of house lettuce mix, roma tomatoes, hard boiled eggs, bacon, black olives, dry bleu cheese crumbles, served with your choice of dressing on the side $10.99
Balsamic Chicken Salad House lettuce mix, with tomatoes, pickled cucumbers, roasted red peppers, fresh feta cheese and grilled chicken tossed in our house-made balsamic dressing $10.99


A Columbus award winner for the last 30 years, our family dough recipe is made fresh daily, assembled with your favorite ingredients, and baked to perfection. Since our stromboli and pizza start from scratch, please allow 25-40 minutes for these items.

Everyone's Favorite Stromboli

Choose a size:
Small serves 1 $9.99
Medium serves 2-3 $17.99
Large serves 4-6 $19.99
choose which of our signature stromboli you want to eat:
Original Stuffed with pepperoni & sausage, mozzarella & provolone cheese and served with a side of marinara dipping sauce
Chicken Rolled with grilled chicken, tomatoes, banana peppers, mozzarella & provolone cheese and served with red sauce on the side
Vegetarian "Run it thru the garden" Our fresh dough packed full of onions, artichokes, tomatoes, black olives, mozzarella & provolone cheese and served with marinara sauce for dipping


Size 1 Topping Extra Topping Add chicken Veggie Pizza Deluxe
8" $8.99 $.99 $1.99 $10.99 $12.99
12" $10.99 $1.49 $2.59 $14.99 $16.99
14" $11.99 $1.99 $3.19 $18.99 $19.99




Specialty Pizzas:
Award Winning "Meats Pizza" A gourmet blend of cheeses with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni and salami 8" - 11.99, 12" - 16.49, 14" - 19.49
"Frank's Favorite Pizza" Our famous crust brushed with garlic and olive oil, topped with tomatoes, spinach, mozzarella, provolone and feta cheese 8"" - 10.99, 12"" - 14.99, 14"" - 17.49


All of our sandwiches are prepared on warm toasted bread and served with your choice of pasta salad, cup of soup or parmesan fries.

Sausage & Peppers Mama's slow cooked Italian sausage topped with sautéed roasted red peppers, green peppers & onions $8.99
The Italian Stallion Our famous Italian hoagie with savory ham, salami, capicola ham, pepperoni, with lettuce, tomatoes, onion, banana peppers, provolone cheese and balsamic dressing $8.99
Millie's Meatball Hoagie topped with homemade red sauce sauce, banana peppers and melted provolone cheese $8.99
The Godfather A prime steak hoagie with sautéed roasted red peppers, green peppers, mushrooms, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions with a side of creamy horseradish sauce $8.99
The Godmother Lightly fried chicken breast topped with homemade red sauce and melted provolone, shredded lettuce and roma tomatoes $8.99
Veggie Hoagie Fresh mushrooms, roasted red peppers, spinach, roma tomatoes and fresh mozzarella and a light spread of basil pesto $8.99
1/2 lb. Angus Burger served with onions, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles. Add provolone, American or Bleu Cheese - .79 Add sautéed mushrooms or bacon for .99 $8.99
Buffalo Chicken Philly Grilled chicken strips, sauteed with green peppers & red onions, topped with a spicy buffalo sauce, shredded lettuce and roma tomatoes $8.99
Westerville's Best Fish Sandwich With lettuce, tomatoes and side of tartar sauce $8.99


Entrees come with a homemade roll. add house or caesar with entree purchase $2.99

Baked Ziti Chunks of meatball, sausage and pepperoni tossed in tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella and provolone cheese $10.99
Chicken Carsonie Lightly breaded chicken topped with marinara sauce & provolone cheese served with spaghetti alfredo $11.99
Lasagna Deep dish style with layers of fresh pasta, beef, ricotta, mozzarella and provolone cheese layered to perfection $10.99
Meatballs and Spaghetti Italian spiced meatballs tossed in zesty homemade sauce served on a bed of spaghetti $10.99
Ravioli Six cheese ravioli smothered in tomato cream sauce and melted cheese $10.99
Pasta Rosa Penne noodles, roasted chicken, roasted red peppers, spinach and mushrooms tossed in creamy red pepper sauce $11.99
Eggplant Parmesan Fresh eggplant breaded and baked until a crispy golden brown, served with spaghetti all covered with a zesty homemade pasta sauce $10.99
Mediterranean Pasta w/ Shrimp or Chicken Penne pasta with your choice of shrimp or chicken sautéed with olive oil, garlic, tomatoes, spinach and feta cheese $11.99


Kid-friendly cuisine for guests under 12. All items include beverage of your choice


Spaghetti and Meatball Homemade red sauce and one meatball served on the side with our homemade roll
Penne Noodles Tossed lightly in butter served with a side of marinara & a homemade roll
Pizza Mia French bread style pizza with your choice of cheese or pepperoni
Meatball Slider 2 meatball slider sandwiches served on toasted buns with melted cheese and a side of french fries or steamed vegetables
Chicken Fingers Served with a side of french fries or steamed vegetables
Grilled Cheese with a side of french fries or steamed vegetables


Elephant Ear Fried dough dusted with cinnamon sugar $3.95
Tiramisu An Italian tradition, with coffee syrup $4.95
Decadent Chocolate Cake Served with triple bean vanilla ice cream and chocolate sauce $4.95